Photographs are known to capture a moment, and although photos may look the same, many photographers have a different way of achieving that moment. This can be depicted as the photographic style of the photographer. While observing the works of Kertesz and Cartier-Bresson versus Smith and Salgado one can see the two different approaches to photography.
Andre Kertesz and Henri Cartier-Bresson used aerial views, and near and far contrast within their photography. Their approach made them appear as a fly on the wall in their photos. They wanted to appear "invisible" while capturing the image to preserve the character and life, within the photo. This idea makes the moment within the photo real and untouched. The works of Kertesz was described by J. Paul Getty Museum’s Photography Curator, Weston Naef, as "a little like Christopher Columbus, who discovered a new world that, in the end, was named for someone else." (S K Josefburg,1998).
Kerstez focus evolved as did his photography; he begun capturing emotions of people, then later moved on to city scenery, and life. Kertesz style of photography is considered a foundation for photojournalist. Henri Cartier-Bresson acknowledges Kertesz legendary style “Whatever we have done, Kertész did first.”as a good example to express the importance of Kertész in photography. (S K Josefburg, 1998).
Like Kertesz, Henri Cartier- Bresson used his camera to "preserve life in act of living (Fame). Cartier- Bresson style was not focused on art and abstract, but of capturing the essence and personality with the moment. Cartier-Bresson defines his style as ‘the simultaneous recognition, in a fraction of a second, of the significance of an event as well as the precise organization of forms which gives that event its proper expression"(Fame). The goal of Andre Kertesz and Cartier was to reflect the images of everyday life in the simplest form possible. In an instantaneous exposure they would capture human detail, as well as the character of life and reality.
Andre Kertsez
"Ballet'' New York", 1938
Henri Cartier- Bresson
" The Quai St Bernard", 1932
Smith and Salgado's photography style included an interactive connection with their subjects. They would edit and enhance their images to elaborate on the expression they wished to portray. Smith and Salgado did not worry about being invisible when capturing an image. They would envision the photo, and enhance it with lighting, focus and other objects to achieve its perfection. The one thing these four photographers had in common was the elaborate time they would take to develop and capture the perfect moment. Andre and Henri would spend months to years waiting to capture the perfect bird landing. While Smith and Salgado would spend days to make sure they emphasized the perfect expression within an image. All four made sure what they envisioned was portrayed in their photos.
Sebastiao Salgado
"Gourma-Rharous Mali",1985
Eugene Smith
"Awaiting survivors of the Andrea Doria", 1956
What’s the better journalistic approach?
It really is hard to choose which journalistic approach is best.. They all have their pros and cons. Kertesz and Cartier-Bresson appear to have a better approach. Kertsez and Cartier- Bresson photographs depict an action, setting, or situation that will only occur once. It is trickier to capture something that is only available for a short period of time. These photographs are original; nothing is staged or propped out, adjusted, or distorted from actual reality. There is no biased approach or sentiment in the background, the photograph portrays the location, position, and condition precisely as if you were there yourself. Most of the photographs taken by Kertesz and Cartier-Bresson were improvised; the subjects in the pictures didn’t pose or force their movements, like Smith and Salgado photographs. Yes, Salgado and Smith attempted to show the audience more feeling and dramatization, but sometimes this is exaggerated and interpreted the wrong way. The “invisible” and “in the moment” style of documentary photography would be the better method.
By: Fernando Elizondo, Darren Messam, , and Yasiel Sambra
Work Cited
Henri Cartier-Bresson. Web. 17 July 2011.
Fame. http://www.photo-seminars.com/Fame/bresson.htm
"Andre Kertesz". SK Josefburg Studios. Web. 17 July 2011. http://www.urban-photography-art.com/andre-kertesz.html
Class Notes Week 10: https://gbc.blackboard.com/webct/urw/lc5122011.tp0/cobaltMainFrame.dowebct
Photo Credit
Andre Kertsez
http://www.higherpictures.com/ImageViewer.aspx?id=384
Henri Cartier-Bresson
http://www.magnumphotos.com/Catalogue/Henri-Cartier-Bresson/1932/FRANCE-1932-NN145909.html
Sebastiao Selgado
http://www.masters-of-photography.com/S/salgado/salgado_mali_full.html
Eugene Smith
http://www.oocities.org/minoltaphotographyw/williameugenesmith02.html